China’s Modern Day Ghost Cities
April 3, 2025
The GDP system has found several criticisms. However, none of the criticisms have been as apparent as an unusual phenomenon called “ghost cities” and “ghost towns” which have cropped up all across China. The sheer wastage and diversion of resources to non productive purposes to meet the government’s targets for GDP growth is apparent in…
In the previous article, we learned about the concept of the broken window fallacy. We learned that in general, the GDP concept disregards destruction. It takes a lopsided view and only considers the additions that have happened to the economy as a result of the war. The GDP concepts conveniently omits out the destructions caused…
The fact that GDP is a broken system is well known. Many countries across the world have attempted to create an alternate index. The idea has always been to correct the flaws of the GDP system and provide a better metric to measure progress. However, none of the countries have ventured out as far as…
We have spoken in great detail about GDP. By now, we are aware of the dangers of setting GDP maximization as a country’s prime economic objective. To study more about the GDP we need to have a closer look at what it is made up of i.e. its components. Once we know the components and the way they are calculated, we can delve further into their pros and cons.
Hence, at a macro level, we can say that GDP is the sum of all the goods and services produced within a nation’s boundaries. However, not all goods are the same and not all producers are the same. Some types of goods benefit the economy more than the others and same is the case with producers. Hence, for a thorough analysis of GDP, it is essential to bifurcate the GDP into its component parts.
The first bifurcation happens between domestic trade and foreign trade. We first separate the goods produced for our own consumption from goods that were sent abroad. Then the next level of bifurcation happens within the domestic goods.
Domestic goods are then segregated into goods produced by the private sector and goods produced by the public sector i.e. the government.
Further the goods produced by the private sector are then subdivided into goods produced for immediate consumption and goods that will act as capital investment and aid the production of goods in the future.
The components of GDP can therefore be expressed in the form of this equation:
GDP = C + I + G + (X - M)
Wherein:
Let’s study each of these components in greater detail
Consumption represents all the goods and services that were purchased by households’ i.e. individual consumers. This component of the GDP is the best indicator of the purchasing power in any given economy.
A higher C number relative to the total GDP is considered a good sign. This means that the economy is driven by the market i.e. by consumer spending and is not artificially inflated.
Investment, also referred to as fixed investment is the amount of capital goods added by a country in a given year. It is very important to segregate the goods produced for present consumption versus the goods that will aid in maximizing production in the forthcoming years. The I component gives a good idea about what the GDP of an economy in the future years will be.
A higher investment in capital goods by the economy is a good sign implying that production is expected to take off in the forthcoming years. The “I” component is further divided into residential and non residential investments. This is because residential investments do not necessarily mean higher production in the future whereas industrial investments do.
The next component is government spending. This is the component that has been criticized in great detail in the past few articles. Government spending simply measures the amount of money spent by the government in any given year. This expenditure does not include transfer payments i.e. payments for social security or unemployment benefits.
A higher government spending has often been correlated with poorly managed economies. However, this does not necessarily have to be the case. Countries like China have become economic powerhouses despite the fact that a substantial part of their GDP still comes from the “G” component.
The next component is the net exports i.e. X-M. Now just the fact that imports are being subtracted from the GDP often given imports a negative connotation. However, this is not true. Imports are subtracted from the GDP to avoid double counting. This is because imports have already been considered under the “C” component.
Imports are not necessarily harmful to the country and may in fact aid in more judicious use of the natural resources that are available at a country’s disposal.
It is important to segregate foreign trade from domestic markets. This gives economists an idea as to what drives the GDP.
If the GDP of a nation is export driven, then a slowdown in other countries will have an adverse impact on the GDP.
On the other hand, if an economy is driven by internal consumption and has less dependency on foreign markets, then the GDP will be less affected by a slowdown in other markets.
To sum it up, the analysis of the GDP can only be done by dividing it further into smaller and smaller categories. These components still provide only a macro level picture of the economy. Economic analyses go further into the details trying to find out exactly what goods, sectors or markets are driving the GDP number.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *